Reviews

BOOK REVIEW: No Sad Songs by Frank Morelli

Format: Paperback, ARC
Links: Goodreads | Amazon UK
Blurb: Following a family tragedy, 18-year-old Gabe LoScuda suddenly finds himself thrust into the role of caregiver for his ailing grandfather. Between the shopping trips and the doctor visits with Grandpa, Gabe and his friend John try to salvage their senior year, meet girls, and make the varsity baseball team. It doesn’t take long for Gabe to realize that going to school and looking after a grandfather with Alzheimer’s is more work than he ever imagined.

And when long-lost Uncle Nick appears on the scene, Gabe soon finds that living with Nick and Grandpa is like babysitting two grown men. Aside from John, the only person who truly understands Gabe is Sofia, a punk-rocking rebel he meets at the veteran’s hospital. When these three unlikely friends are faced with a serious dilemma, will they do what it takes to save Grandpa? If there’s a chance of preserving the final shreds of Grandpa’s dignity, Gabe may have to make the most gut-wrenching decision of his life—and there’s no way out.


Review: I don’t often accept review requests any more. In fact, I never do. I’m just too busy and if you’re a book blogger, you’ll know that getting so many requests can certainly get a little overwhelming. Sigh, so many books, so little time. But when the email for No Sad Songs landed in my inbox, I was instantly intrigued. So, against my own rules, I decided to accept it and was kindly sent a copy to review. So thank you to Fish Out of Water Books for sending this to me! I love YA books – I definitely need to read more of them and this sounded right up my street. It’s about Gabe, a high school student who is a full-time carer for his Grandpa, who has an advanced form of Alzheimer’s Disease.

Gabe’s entire life revolves around his Grandpa and above anything, this book really did make me gain a much higher appreciation of anyone in Gabe’s situation. Anyone who is a carer to someone with Alzheimer’s or Dementia. I’ve not had a solid experience of knowing someone with the disease in it’s severe and advanced stages so I can’t pretend to even understand what that must be like for the families and friends who take care of them. So before we go any further, I take my metaphorical hat off to you.

Back to the book. Despite the important messages within in – I kinda looked at it as a less-whimsical version of a John Green book (and that’s not a bad thing, John Green is one of my favourite authors) – there was a fair bit going on and the story-line definitely didn’t go where I thought it would. Although I didn’t necessarily agree with a lot of Gabe’s decisions throughout the book, they were certainly admirable. But again, that goes back to the fact that Gabe is in this situation that not many teenage kids find themselves in. If I was in the same scenario, would I have acted the same? It’s hard to say.

I have some negatives, the main one being that there’s an awful lot of talk about Baseball in this book and for someone who knows nothing about the sport (nor particularly cares – I’m from England and we don’t really do Baseball over here), I found these parts a real struggle and admittedly did skim over a good few chunks of text which may as well have been written in Chinese for all I knew. Another similar point was when Gabe and his best friend John were playing a video game. I was lost. Speaking of John, he was a wonderful character. I instantly fell in love with John after a fair early chapter where Gabe has to deal with quite a distressing situation with his Grandpa and John doesn’t say anything, just gets on and helps. It was really admirable and I can only hope I’m that kind of person one day.

The plot itself was good; I wouldn’t go as far as saying it’s great. If anything, I would have liked to see more of Grandpa in the book and less of Gabe’s obsession with this girl in his school. Although the high school / romance elements of the book compared to the quite serious aspects were a nice contrast. I would have also liked to see more flashbacks of Gabe’s childhood with his Grandpa and his parents. We do see a few of these throughout and they were all really lovely. I’d probably say the story felt a little scattered sometimes. But overall, was exceptionally readable.

A quick, easy to read book absolutely perfect for young adults. It deals with situations that most of them won’t be familiar with and will certainly give readers who haven’t dealt with Alzheimer’s or Dementia before and insight into what it’s like to be a carer – albeit, a bit of a fictional insight. I think this book holds a lot of clever and meaningful messages and was a fun read, despite the difficult elements of the book.

Advertisements

Jenny in Neverland

Twenty-something lifestyle blogger from Essex. Book lover, Slytherin, organisational wizard and enjoys Motorsport, Disney and Yoga.

29 Comments

  1. […] this year, I was sent a copy of No Sad Songs by Frank Morelli to review. Now I don’t usually accept review requests anymore; in fact, I never do. As much […]

  2. The cover of this book immediately jumped out at me when I clicked the link. I’m adding it to my book wishlist.

    Amy | hookedonthemusic.com

    1. It’s quite dramatic isn’t it! xxx

  3. kattieh says:

    This sounds like such an interesting read. It’s a great topic to write about, and such an important one for YA readers.

    1. Totally agree 🙂 xxx

  4. From the bio I am intrigued by the book too! I can see why you accepted to write a review on it. Young carers is a topic rarely touched, even in literature, so it’s so refreshing to hear a plot based on it x x x

    1. Oh absolutely it’s great that there’s some awareness of it! xxx

  5. My nanny had Alzheimer’s and it was really hard to watch, but I really like when books shed a light on that. I’m not sure it would keep my interest if the focus is more romance-based though, although it does sound like an interesting mix of topics!
    Beth x

    1. It wasn’t entirely romance focused at all, I hate romance so I couldn’t have read it if it was! xxx

  6. Kirstie Wheeler says:

    Sports references will forever go over my head, however, the book does sound somewhat like a good read if you’re wanting to introduce the topic of Dementia/Alzheimers to a young person.

    1. Haha same here, apart from Formula 1. Anything else and I might as well be reading German.

  7. Sounds like an absolutely amazing read! I’m definitely going to check this out!

    Love, Amie ❤
    The Curvaceous Vegan

    1. It was very good 🙂

  8. It sounds like a great read x

    http://www.ofbeautyandnothingness.co.uk

    1. It was c

  9. I loved reading your review! This probably isn’t my kind of genre, but this does sound like a good read. I love that you get an insight into the life of a dementia carer in this, as you said I think this would make a lot of people understand how it impacts the families emotionally x

    Kate | http://www.katelovesx.co.uk

    1. I hope it does anyway! xxx

  10. I’d would definitely pick this up in a bookshop and read more as I really like the arty cover. I learned a lot about the science behind Alzheimer’s and Dementia in my studies so would be interested to read a story on how it impacts families. Thanks for the honest review Jenny! 💖 xx

    Bexa | http://www.hellobexa.com

    1. Wow really?! I bet that was fascinating! xxx

  11. based on the synopsis alone I think I would accept this one as well… I hear you about the crazy amount of requests book reviewers get lol

    1. Haha it’s ridiculous isn’t it!

  12. Sounds like quite a good read xx

    1. It was indeed

  13. Definitely sounds like an interesting concept! My father is a Personal Support Worker for the elderly so, I get to hear all the time how hard it is to care for those with Alzheimer’s and dimensia. I’m so glad I haven’t had to deal with it extensively myself yet. It seems like it would be very painful to see in someone I love.

    1. Wow your Dad sounds like an amazing man, I bet that’s a difficult job xxx

  14. Sounds like an interesting book. I don’t think I would go out of my way to buy it but if I happened to come across it I would give it a chance.

    1. I’m inclined to agree but I was certainly intrigued by it xxx

  15. Sounds like a great book for a young teenager. However, I agree that if you don’t like sports you may get a little bit bored of the book. 🌸✨

    With love, Alisha Valerie x | AlishaValerie.com

    1. I didn’t get bored, it wasn’t massively in the book, just a few pages here and there xx

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.